what if and what's next?

Adapted from a talk I gave to English majors at Virginia Tech. It's about ai.

what if and what's next?
A typical fall morning on the Drillfield in the middle of Virginia Tech's campus.
This post is adapted from the script for a talk I gave at the Virginia Tech English Department's annual Career Connections event.

As part of the alumni board, I get to go back every year to meet with staff and students. We talk about the state of the department and what it means to be out here in the world as an English major.

Not surprisingly, this year focused a lot on AI and its implications for new grads. These are my thoughts.


OK. A quick TLDR, so you know why I’m here to talk about this.

I left here in 2005. After a few stop-the-bleeding jobs (waiting tables, tutoring for SAT writing exams… the things people expected me to do with an English degree), my first real job was as a copywriter for a marketing agency. Working for another former alumni board member, actually.

Then I joined an early ecommerce software company to work on marketing and help redesign their website.

And one day the product manager came over and said, “We have 3 designers over there redesigning the software and no one’s ever worked on the words in the interface. Would you like to come help?"

I did, and I never came back.

A year or so later I got recruited to join the content strategy team at Facebook working on their advertising and business tools.

I’ve worked at companies like Autodesk and Shopify, and currently at Block, where I most recently worked on Cash App.

For all of those jobs, I’ve mostly focused on the content in the interface, and then building tools and guidance for other people focused on the content in the interface.

Until last year. When I started working on our AI tools.

I was still building for designers and content designers (and everyone else in the company), but I wasn’t just writing or working on writing tools anymore. I was working on everything. From writing, to design, to code, I'm able to work on any part of the job. From start to finish. For better or for worse.

That’s really want I want to talk about today.

But first, I want to go back. Way back.


In 1494, a Benedictine abbot named Johannes Trithemius wrote a treatise called In Praise of Scribes.

The printing press was spreading across Europe. Books and religious texts could be printed in a fraction of the time and cost. And scribes were starting to lose their jobs.

In his treatise, Johannes celebrated their artistry, the quality of the vellum that had lasted hundreds of years already, and argued that people who had acquired large libraries of books inexpensively were “concealing their laziness.” (Sounds familiar?)

But Johannes had an urgent problem.

He needed to get a lot of copies out as quickly as possible...

Yep 😅

He took his treatise to the local printing press and had copies made to distribute to anyone he could get it to.

Not surprisingly, this wasn’t hugely successful, and only one run was ever printed.

I always loved that story for the irony. A funny anecdote about someone with the best intentions, but who was holding onto the past, fighting the future, and ultimately unable to escape it.

Maybe I’ve softened in my old age, but these days I feel where Johannes is coming from, and that kind of frames the rest of my talk today.

We find ourselves facing a similar seismic shift in technology now.

Jobs are changing. Whole industries are at risk. People are scared.

And I don’t think we can treatise our way out of this one either.


When I was getting started, I feel in love with a couple of books by an NYU professor named Clay Shirky called Here Comes Everybody (book / TED talk) and Cognitive Surplus (book / TED talk).

In these books, he explored the rise of social media, self publishing, and online communities. That’s also where I learned the story about Johannes.

That shift was not quite as dramatic as the one we’re facing now, but it was a big change for publishing and communications.

And it gave me opportunities, as an English major, that I wouldn’t have had before.

I didn't study marketing, but I knew writing. In that first job as a copywriter, I wrote ads, billboards, brochures. Eventually I worked on brand strategies and market research reports. I learned how to map out websites and basic apps.

It was a new kind of work, but not really that new. Most of it was just a digital version of what had come before:

  • Those emails were digital mailers.
  • The digital ads were magazine ads formatted for a website.
  • The websites we made were basically online brochures.
  • Social media marketing was a Facebook page with a mix of status updates and pasting the ads we made for other sites.

(In our defense, even Facebook didn’t know what Facebook marketing was yet. My team was still figuring that out when I went to work there 5 years later.)


There’s actually a long history of this when new technology flips an industry on its head.

First inclination is just to do the same thing you’ve been doing but with the new thing:

  • The first movies were plays in front of a camera.
  • The music was created by orchestras and conductors in a pit in front the screen.
  • The first radio shows were vaudeville acts on a mic.
  • The first tv shows were radio shows in front of a camera.
  • The first apps were just websites packaged up on a phone.

People bring the baggage of what they know. They try to stick the new technology onto the old thing and call it innovation.

That’s where we are today with AI.

  • What if search but with ai?
  • What if email reply but with ai?
  • What if car radio but with ai?
  • What if toilet but with ai? (I wish I was kidding)

While this is happening, there’s also a parallel stream of people who look at new technology and rage against it.

  • There was the defense of scribes.
  • In 1906 the composer John Philip Sousa wrote The Menace of Mechanical Music, where he warned that the phonograph would become "a substitute for human skill, intelligence and soul." (Sounds familiar)
  • In the 1920s, the unions for those pit orchestras at the movies protested against “canned music” that was being added to movies. (See Jeffrey Katzenberg on AI for Creativity)
  • As social media took off, publishers railed against the lower quality of citizen journalism and independent producers.

It’s usually positioned as a defense of quality or a moral stand for others. But it’s also about money.

  • The abbeys made money selling hand-copied books.
  • The phonograph producers were selling Sousa’s music without paying him. (His treatise actually helped lead to the first copyright laws in the US.)
  • Canned music for movies put hundreds, maybe thousands of local musicians out of work.
  • People reporting on Twitter were breaking news and getting scoops ahead of print and tv journalists, for free.
  • And people I work with today are losing their jobs across the industry because of AI.

But eventually, people start to understand the new technology as a new medium. They start to imagine what’s next. What it can be that wasn’t possible before.

In Cognitive Surplus, Shirky showed how the shift from passively watching TV to actively participating in online forums and social networking made Wikipedia possible.

From individually consuming to individually publishing to collectively creating the largest, peer reviewed source of knowledge, ever.

Let’s go back one last time to our friend Johannes and his neighborhood printing press.

It's still funny.

But on the other hand, it’s also the story of someone with a unique experience and perspective, who recognized what was happening around him, and begrudgingly or not, accepted that the best way to accomplish his goals was to use this new technology to his advantage.

He embraced it for what it made possible – for what he couldn't have realistically done before.

But he still did his thing. The part he was uniquely qualified to do.

And it changed him.

From a scribe to an author.

From someone who spent months or years hand-copying a book someone else had written, to a writer who published his thoughts for the world.

Thoughts that we can still read 500 years later.

He brought his skills to this new reality and made a path forward.


Look, I don't think my perspective on the current shifts in the world will be nearly as impactful on generations 500 years from now. But hopefully they’re helpful to you here today.

I owe my early career to the technologies that were changing the world when I got out of here.

The traditional paths – newspapers, magazines, book publishing – all faced headwinds then, and they’re even stronger today.

But, turns out...

People still wanted to read things on the web.

That growing ecosystem of social media apps, targeted advertising, and content creation platforms needed people who understood the power of language.

I didn’t know it when I was here, but I was getting a hands-on education in one of the most important skills in that new economy.

And I’ve built on top of that at every step:

  • from traditional creative and academic writing
  • to writing for print and advertising
  • to online ads and websites
  • to the writing inside software and applications
  • to designing software and application experiences
  • to building the tools others use to design and write for those experiences.

I didn't plan for most of those changes. But I was always open to them. Looking for them. Making them happen when I had to.

But it was up to me to bring my experience from each step into the next.

To meet the moment. To become something I couldn’t be before.

So what does this mean for you?


Like cognitive surplus supersized, AI tools give even more people even more access to contribute to this universe of information and entertainment.

The difference is, the majority of them are leaving the cognition to the robots.

But those tools don’t actually think. They don’t have cognition. What they have is access to massive, massive reserves of written information.

They aren’t intelligence. They are scripts built on large language models.

And that’s where you come in. It says it on the label — language models. This new, fundamental shift in technology runs on the thing you're studying.

You majored in the fuel that makes this whole thing possible. It uses language, guided with language, to largely produce language.

And the irony is that language is cognition. Writing is thinking.

Here’s a quote from recent Guardian article with the definitely-not-clickbait title “AI is rotting your brain”:

"Overusing artificial intelligence affects the brain and learning by bypassing the mental effort required to build deep neural connections, a process known as cognitive offloading.

Frequent AI use fosters a passive acceptance of information, reducing the internal friction and inquiry that drive genuine curiosity and problem-solving.

The brain depends on mental struggle and overcoming failure to rewire and strengthen our neural pathways. Bypassing that friction reduces our overall cognitive reserve over time.”

OK, that’s a bit dramatic, but I see the signs of this every day. I’m sure your professors in the room here see signs of this every day.

I see too many people using AI for exploration, strategy, creative work, or even their communications with other people.

Don’t let it have that. Lean into the friction and the human connection.

Do the creative, hard, infuriating, gratifying thinking work. Make it do the boring data collection, organization, and analysis.

It can’t do my laundry yet but it can at least do my spreadsheets. Then I can focus on the fun parts of my job.


But I'll be honest; this also sucks. There’s a lot about this shift that’s really detrimental to… everything.

AI poses real risks in misinformation, hacking, fraud, and national security.

Data centers are a real threat to the climate and to communities.

A lot of people have lost and will lose jobs.

And the slopification of everything drags down creative people and creative work across the board.

And… I miss em-dashes. I love an em-dash. And I’ll never forgive AI for taking that from me.


So, in the face of that, what do we do? What can you do?

Last month, my entire design team got together in New York, and our head of design, Brooke Ellis, said something that's stuck with me.

She summed up the work of design (and writers) in this moment as this: “Imagine what should exist.”

Sit with that for a second.

Imagine what should exist.

Right now, everybody’s focused on the “imagine.” But they skip over the “should.”

Not “could.” Not “can.” Should.

That’s the work today. That's the grown-up part.

What’s missing or lacking or wrong in this technology?

What can it do to help people improve their conditions?

How can it help people do things they didn’t have access to?

Or things that were impossible before now?

And with “what should” also comes “what shouldn’t?”

Where should we put up boundaries?

What should we keep for ourselves or protect for others?

How can we use it to fight against those risks it creates?

Fortunately, you will leave here with a lot of what you need to face these new challenges and opportunities.

You’re learning empathy and awareness and critical thinking.

You’re analyzing intentions, understanding consequences, finding meaning in nuance.

You’re debating ethics and values in ways that are sorely lacking in my industry today.

I know you probably don't feel like grown-ups right now, but you're better prepared for this moment than most.


So for now, put it to work for you:

  • Use it to take the load off of something mind-numbing or time-consuming so you can focus on the real cognitive friction you have access to here.
  • Or make a portfolio website that’s more impressive than anything I could have done with a team of people 2 years ago.
  • Or build something ridiculous that makes your friends laugh and blows your parents’ minds because they have no idea how you did it.

But learn something about it, how it works, what it can and can’t do yet. Then see where you can take it:

  • What’s missing in your world today that it makes possible?
  • What is that you uniquely have the experience and perspective to do with it?
  • What can you do collectively? What’s the cognitive surplus of all of you plus all of your robots working together?

You might feel like you’re behind, but I promise, you’re here at the start.

And you've got all the pieces.

You're trained in the fuel these future machines run on.

You're practiced in the skills people need to wield them.

And you're attuned to the perspectives and awareness that are woefully lacking in the work they’re doing.

You're here for the what if. You're primed for the what’s next. And we need all help we can get with the what should.

That’s it. Thanks. Go Hokies.